It’s Astonishing How Little The Rings of Power Resembles The Lord of the Rings
A deep dive into the ways in which the new Amazon series departs from Tolkien's beloved fantasy epic.
Character Changes and Inaccuracies
- Galadriel is portrayed as a warrior, while in the books she is a wise and powerful elf.
- Elrond is depicted as a young and ambitious elf, whereas Tolkien describes him as a wise and experienced leader.
Timeline Discrepancies
- The series condenses thousands of years of history into a single season, altering the timeline of events described in the books.
- The forging of the Rings of Power is depicted as a major event, although Tolkien wrote that it was a gradual process.
Mythological Deviations
- The series introduces a new character, Adar, who serves as the main antagonist. However, no such character appears in Tolkien's mythology.
- The orcs are presented as having a complex and tragic backstory, which differs from Tolkien's portrayal of them as inherently evil creatures.
Narrative Liberties
- The series invents several new storylines and characters that do not align with Tolkien's writings.
- The show incorporates elements of modern fantasy and adventure tropes that are not found in the original works.
Conclusion
While "The Rings of Power" may offer some entertainment value, its significant departures from Tolkien's vision diminish its authenticity and connection to the beloved Middle-earth universe.
Komentar